DID SUBLIMOTION (IBIZA) COPY ULTRAVIOLET (SHANGHAI) ?

We love Chef Paul Pairet’s Ultraviolet restaurant in Shanghai (www.uvbypp.cc). We have followed the place since its opening in 2012.

Undoubtedly one of the most innovative restaurants anywhere, but above all one of the best when it comes to food.

The recent opening of Sublimotion (www.sublimotionibiza.com), a very similar project from Chef Paco Roncero in Ibiza (2 years after Ultraviolet!) came as a shock.

At first we thought that Pairet was involved in this new restaurant – But no – Sublimotion has not much to do with Pairet and Ultraviolet.

It is simply a copycat concept, with similar structure, looks and design and descriptions.

Luckily… they did not copy the food…

Roncero claims that he “had a dream”, pretends to be genuine, “unseen”, and talks lengthily about how hard it was to conceive such a project!

He proudly positions his project as “the most expensive restaurant in the world”… but forgot purposely to acknowledge Ultraviolet’s direct influence.

Lack of honesty, lack of ethic, lack of ideas… we felt this was too much: “A cat is a cat – a copycat is not a cat… It’s a copycat – Bravo!” – PP

Maybe Mr. Roncero thought that he would get away in reproducing a genuinely innovative project born in China

simply because China is generally inclined to copy than to create?

We decided to enquire, to search, to compile… we talked to Ultraviolet’s team…

They were simply stunned by what we found and the complete lack of ethic from the Ibiza project.

See for yourself and feel free to react.


ULTRA ZORRO & CO

DESIGN & SCENARIOS

ULTRAVIOLET
SUBLIMOTION (Opened two years after Ultraviolet)
UV simulation
Ultraviolet Dining Room simulation
Set as Set as a preview of the project in 2010 for the opening of the website
ONLINE SIMULATION RENDERING
Sublimotion simulation table rendering
Sublimotion dining room simulationShockingly similar simulation, and the table scenarios you are about to see below…

Entrance Metal Lift ultraViolet
Ultraviolet entrance / Metal industrial lift
-
ENTRANCE DESIGN
Entrance Metal Lift SublimotionSublimotion entrance / Metal industrial lift | Video screenshot: YoutubeWhat is the point to have imitated as well the design direction on a room which could have taken a lot of other influence?

UV GUEST NAME PROJECTIONUltraviolet dining room: Name projectionUpon arrival, names of the guests are projected on the table.
GUEST NAME PROJECTION
Sublimotion GUEST NAME PROJECTION
Sublimotion dining room: Name projectionUpon arrival, names of the guests… you know… like in Ultraviolet.

UV SCENARIO: DESCENDINGUltraviolet dining room: Descending scenarioVideo screenshot: The New York Times. Guests feel like descending through a giant lift taking them in the universe of Ultraviolet.
INTRO SCENARIO LIFT EFFECT DESCENDING
Sublimotion SCENARIO: DESCENDINGSublimotion dining room: Descending scenario Video screenshot: The Telegraph. Of course, they couldn’t miss this idea to copy, either. Well, the Newspaper is different…

UV SCENARIO: WILD FIELD
Ultraviolet dining room: Wheat field
Scenario from the first menu 2011-2012 – on a decadent Cheese course
SCENARIO: WILD FIELD
SCENARIO: WILD FIELD
Sublimotion dining room: FieldThe proportion of the table-chair set up and the room is the same as Ultraviolet’s room, except 2 more chairs. 12 chairs instead of 10. Is Paco playing Jesus at the end?

UV SCENARIO: UNDER THE SEA
Ultraviolet dining room: Aquarium / under the sea
By the way, a dish paying tribute to Alain Ducasse… official first guest of Ultraviolet in November 2011 before the formal opening
SCENARIO: UNDER THE SEA
Sublimotion SCENARIO: UNDER THE SEA
Sublimotion dining room: Aquarium / under the seaVery different this time… it is blue!

UV SCENARIO: SEASIDE
Ultraviolet dining room: Seacoast
SCENARIO: SEASIDE
Sublimotion SCENARIO: SEASIDE
Sublimotion dining room: Beach

UV SCENARIO: CITY SCENE
Ultraviolet dining room: City view, Shanghai
UVA 2012… but they have also a view of Paris… just after this one.
SCENARIO: CITY SCENE
Sublimotion SCENARIO: CITY SCENE
Sublimotion dining room: City view, Paris

UV SCENARIO: FOREST, WOOD
Ultraviolet dining room: Forest/Wood
SCENARIO: FOREST, WOOD
Sublimotion SCENARIO: FOREST, WOOD
Sublimotion dining room: Forest / Wood

UV SCENARIO: FOREST, WOOD
Ultraviolet dining room: Picnic / Green meadows
UVB May 2013… Grass on the table for 3 dishes on the theme of the picnic – radio and Co – A beautiful moment
SCENARIO: PARK, GRASS, PICNIC
Sublimotion SCENARIO: FOREST, WOOD
Sublimotion dining room: Park / GrassA beautiful copy of another Ultraviolet’s major theme

UV SCENARIO: SCENARIO: PICNIC
Ultraviolet dining room: Picnic, green meadows | Image source: T of The New York Times

UVB May 2013… Grass on the table for 3 dishes on the theme of the picnic – radio and Co – A beautiful moment

SCENARIO: PICNIC
Sublimotion SCENARIO: SCENARIO: PICNIC
Sublimotion dining room: Picnic, grass | Image source: Instagram Picnic on the grass in a park… exactly same theme as Ultraviolet’s

PROJECT TIMELINE

Paul Pairet / Ultraviolet Shanghai (opened on May 18th 2012)

Paco Roncero / Sublimotion Ibiza (opened on June 1st 2014)

1996
“The Last Supper”: Paul Pairet’s Original project, Sydney Australia

1996 Sydney, Paul Pairet drafted his first project of a single table to cook at his own best.

A table of 12… A fixed menu / cooking alone / setting light mood and music / The project will not open.

2002 – 2003
Baccarat “Crystal Room”: Project planned to open Place de Etats Unis Paris-France

A table of 10, same as today without so much technology (scent in pressure steamer, no projection…) /

Involving Jean Louis Costes & Julie Andrieu with the crystal brand Baccarat/P Starck design. Project cancelled after 3-month planning.

2004
“Table of 10″ : Project planned for Setai GHM Hotel, Miami USA

A table of 10, same as above trying to open within a Hotel room / first concept draft in French “Table de 10″. Project cancelled.

Oct. 2008
“Ultraviolet”: Project planned with VOL, Shanghai China

Paul Pairet joined VOL Group in Oct 2008 to open consecutively Mr & Mrs Bund and Ultraviolet/

First UV intro / sketch / brochure 1st edition

Dec. 2008
Ultraviolet project hit Spain

How did Paco Roncero know about Ultraviolet before anybody else ?

Paul Pairet sent the project of Ultraviolet to Adam Melonas, his ex-sous chef at Jade on 36/ Shangri-La Shanghai

who had been recently hired by Roncero – Madrid Spain.

Adam received Ultraviolet’s project, shared it enthusiastically with Roncero,

and mailed back to express the wish to be the first to experience Ultraviolet at opening together with… Roncero.

From that time, the idea of opening a multi-sensory project will trigger Adam and Roncero:

From an aborted project in Dubai (Adam-Roncero) to another attempt in New York (Adam).

Sep. 2009
Ultraviolet Design and Architectural concept first draft

Project location sourced – first contact with architectural team to build the project

Feb. 2010
Ultraviolet’s first public presentation at the Omnivore Festival OFF5 in Deauville France

Nearly 2 years before the official opening, Paul Pairet presented his project to a full set of Chefs

at the 5th Omnivore Food Festival (OFF 5) in Deauville France.

Ultraviolet project website goes online (www.uvbypp.cc)

UV brochure 2nd edition goes online – explaining publicly the project (Detailed Brochure / rendering /sketch/ simulation video (www.uvbypp.cc/video/)

Feb. 2010
First Architectural Project Draft (Naco Shanghai followed by Magma Design Spain)

Jul. 2011
Ultraviolet’s Brochure final release sent directly to Roncero

The final brochure of Ultraviolet was directly sent to Roncero via Pepe Loira inviting him as well as Ferran Adria to visit the project in construction.

Roncero finally declined the invitation – he was already working on his Madrid “Taller” version of the concept (based on the project he received in 2008).

Nov. 2011
Ultraviolet opened unofficially and exclusively for its firs guest: Alain Ducasse

Alain Ducasse, visiting for the first time Shanghai in Nov. 2011 will honor the project by having a first draft demo lunch into an unfinished construction project.

May 2012
Ultraviolet officially opened to the public with its first Menu UVA

On 17 May 2012, Ultraviolet opened officially its “Table Zero” / Auctioned by Sennheiser.

The construction had been delayed over a year but the place will finally open and will be booked out months ahead from the start.

Jun. 2012
Paco Roncero Taller opened in Madrid.

Adam Melonas will ultimately leave from Roncero before this one opened his “Taller” in Madrid in June 2012.

(a few weeks after the official opening of Ultraviolet)

This Madrid project will go quite unnoticed. It was Roncero’s theatrical understanding of Ultraviolet concept.

Only when Roncero understood what Ultraviolet, now already opened, was really about, did he start to envision Sublimotion.

He will study during the next 2 years Ultraviolet to reproduce its structure into Sublimotion.

Apr. 2013
Ultraviolet gets international recognition from Asia

After entering in 8th position of the very first “Asia 50 Best Restaurants”, (scooping along the way the first “Lifetime Achievement of Asia to Mr. Pairet), Ultraviolet will directly enter in position 60 of the “World 50 Best” (extended list) a short year only after opening.

The project will be exposed internationally in major reviews – and is highly noticed within the F&B Trade.

May 2013
UVB : Ultraviolet’s second menu release

Jan. 23, 2014
Paco Roncero visited Ultraviolet & Pairet

A few months before opening Ibiza “Sublimotion” Paco Roncero visited Ultraviolet in Shanghai.

Paul Pairet will lead the visit and answer all questions from Paco who will never explain about his Ibiza project.

Jun. 2014
Paco Roncero Ibiza “Sublimotion” opens (Over 2 years after Ultraviolet)

It is not long before Chefs and customers from Ultraviolet wondered if Pairet is involved in this project. Surprisingly, he was not! Sublimotion was simply a copycat concept, with similar structure, looks, designs and descriptions.

Paco Roncero knows quite well Paul Pairet. Both chefs met in Shanghai in 2007 at Jade on 36, the fine dining from Shangri La Hotel, helmed, at the time, by the French Chef.
Roncero, together with Dani Garcia, were impressed enough by the food, to induce the invitation of Paul Pairet to both
“San Sebastian Lo Mejor de la Gastronomia” and “Madrid Fusion” – the 2 major Spanish Chefs’ congresses.
It is in San Sebastian 2007 that Pairet will recommend Roncero to hire his ex sous chef Adam Melonas – from whom he will learn about the Ultraviolet project ahead of anybody else.
From there, how Mr. Roncero could purposely avoid to acknowledge his direct influence from Ultraviolet,
pretending that Sublimotion was a “dream” and that he had to work hard on this project, remains a mystery.
How he could copy so much the concept and its whole structure without at least mentioning his obvious source, is simply unbearable.
For all we know, when Pairet questioned Roncero about his posture, this one went very vague and insured that he always mentioned about Ultraviolet to the press.
In fact, Roncero has merely mentioned Ultraviolet and in a very condescending way, explaining how, in his case,
the technology serves the food, and presenting Ultraviolet solely as “the first 360 projection restaurant”… what a nerve!

Ultraviolet was indisputably the first restaurant of its kind (preceding of a year another Spanish project “El Somni”, and Sublimotion of 2 years).

There is probably nothing wrong with other chefs investigating this fantastic concept with their own perception.

But in the case of Sublimotion, it is mostly the complete lack of ethic that is the most serious offense to Ultraviolet’s prominence.

THE WEBSITE

THE BOOKING SYSTEM


The first red light came actually with the shameless copy of Ultraviolet’s website by the team from Sublimotion.
A copy of the 3 steps online booking system (up to little useless design feature) as well as of the FAQ.
(This was modified… but we kept the original screen shots.)



UV Booking Homepage
ULTRAVIOLET (Online Calendar System from 2011)
System page: www.uvbypp.cc/bookings | Tailored designed by its in-house design studio ArtBeat since 2011, and officially released to take bookings in April 2012

ONLINE CALENDAR

Booking Homepage
SUBLIMOTION (Online Calendar 2014)
System page | Screenshot on June 24th 2014: www.sublimotionibiza.com/en/reservas_online/
Why did they even copy the little triangle aside of the steps 1,2,3…???? Ridiculous!

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
FAQ | Screenshot on June 24th 2014: http://www.sublimotionibiza.com/en/faq/
Can’t they even think about their own FAQ? More than two third of the questions are from Ultraviolet version.
Booking Homepage
Booking Homepage

Terms & Conditions: http://uvbypp.cc/bookings/terms



UV Booking Homepage
UV Booking Homepage
UV Booking Homepage
TERMS & CONDITIONS
Terms & Conditions | Screenshots from Booking system, June 24th 2014Of course, same as Ultraviolet – How convenient !

Booking Homepage

CONCEPT DESCRIPTION

ULTRAVIOLET

Ultraviolet brochure (www.uvbypp.cc/brochure)


Conceived by Paul Pairet for over 15 years and supported by VOL group, Ultraviolet is the first restaurant of its kind attempting to
unite food with multi-sensorial technology in order to create a fully immersive dining experience.

“No décor, no artifacts, no paintings, no views… Ultraviolet’s dining room is ascetic by nature. Specifically equipped with multi sensorial high-end technology, the dining room is dressed-up by lights,
sounds, music, scents… a cool air blow, an immersive projection, images and imagination… and food.

To offer a bold and exclusive dining experience that engages all the senses to create the ultimate luxury: Emotion

SUBLIMOTION

Website content (www.sublimotionibiza.com)

The key words of description is, of course, similar.

Sublimotion is the achievement of one of Paco Roncero’s dreams in which culinary vanguard and technological innovation unite to create a complete and up to now unseen emotional experience.

It’s advanced systems allow the creation of chromatic atmospheres, the control of the temperature and humidity of the space and the aromatization of the ambience under a musical sequence especially composed for the occasion.

(…) Upon entering, you will see state-of-the-art technology and design flooded with aromas, scenic views, sounds and music, where you are the indisputable protagonist.

Paco Roncero manages this way to conceive an exclusive space in which to experience, for those who get a chance to know it, the most intense emotions.

TEASER VIDEO

Ultraviolet teaser video
http://www.uvbypp.cc/video/teaser/

Sublimotion teaser video:
http://vimeo.com/98687104
How the video ends was done similarly like Ultraviolet.
The whole concept presentation is obviously inspired by Ultraviolet.

  • http://ultracopycat.com/ ultrazorro

    see it!

  • olaf S.

    okay, I was aware of UV project a couple of year ago, this copycat sounds weird.
    Since,paco Roncero removed all above similarities out of their websites, i assume both
    parties are aware and it is indeed a copy/paste. And sublimotion still dare to compete
    on international awards with this copy project. shame!
    we stay tuned about the next outcome of this story.

  • Gab

    Should have patented it!